That's a massive exaggeration. and nobody was taken over by the hebrews. Close. View discussions in 1 other community. then the amorites (babylonians) made it their capital and expanded it. regardless, babylon was "a major city" all throughout the bronze and iron ages. the babylonian conquest of judah and the exile of the political leadership is well documented in history from both sides. The Daughter of Babylon (enemy of Israel) is the subject and the “happy” is the dashing of God’s people through war. Nevertheless, they mourned for their home. 9 Happy is the one who seizes your infants and dashes them against the rocks. (Psalm 137:9 ESV) If we want to take the entire psalter seriously, it’s clear that we need more than romantic notions about God’s gentleness and protection. Nevertheless, they mourned for their home. Exodus 15:3 - The Lord is a man of War; YHVH is his name. save hide report. This is a complicated and difficult question. Most of it isn't even "pleasant". Too often I've seen this be quoted by some to mean: "Your God is terrible because he approves of smashing children on rocks" "Your God/the Bible says killing children brings happiness" But as always, it's important to actually read the psalm. No single verse is an island. Here is the interpretation given by St Theodoros the Great Ascetic: “Every assent in thought to some forbidden desire, that is, every submission to self-indulgence, is … 41 Bible Verse Images for: Babies ranked in order of popularity and relevancy. You can see why non believers point out the hypocrisy. And yet they are the same unchanging god supposedly. And, oh yeah, that's not what God means and he doesn't approve of killing babies. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Psalm 139 The Inescapable God - To the leader. The Daughter of Babylon (enemy of Israel) is the subject and the “happy” is the dashing of God’s people through war. You're admitting the text is just man-made expressions of human emotions. He directly kills off the innocent first born of Egypt (killing innocents to change the heart of a leader whose heart he hardened in the first place if I recall correctly), and commands Israel to kill off every man, woman and child of some of their enemies. There’s no way to sugar coat that if approached in a literal fashion. Sort by. 137:9. Here the psalmist asks God to remember what the babylonians did to Jerusalem, but why? babylon was only occupied by sumerians in the sense that the akkadians unified the sumerian empire. however, that is as far as even the apologetics can take it, and it really seems this is god saying this will be a good act. The Bible pronounces a blessing on baby-killers. save hide report. best. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, ignostic, gnostic atheist, antitheist, 666 repeating. But it doesn't do much to really change the nature of the god as shown in the OT. Still, does the Bible teach that it is okay to kill children? bible.cc/psalms... 24 comments. Yes, I know and have an answer to that thing you're about to type.... yes that other thing too.... and even that...so unless you have something say that's actually relevant to the topic I started... please don't bother me with "muh cult" rhetoric today. We cannot interpret Psalm 137.9 to contradict the rest of the Bible. I find that the problem with this and all attempts to analyze The Book of Psalms is that it's not a work of legal doctrine like Deuteronomy or a work of mythological history like Genesis or Exodus... it's a collection of songs and poems. Press J to jump to the feed. The psalmist is again saying here is your happy song, the ones that will come and destroy you will do evil things like killing your young ones and they will be happy to do so. Heb. @FlyingFree333 so delights in Psalm 137:9 that he creates false re-tweets (RT) from me about Psalm 137:9 and tweets them like they came from me. The answer, of course, is no it doesn't. That verse reads, “Happy is the one who seizes your infants / and dashes them against the rocks.” To “imprecate” means to “pray evil against,” and the Reddit gives you the best of the internet in one place. Who eventually were taken over by the Hebrews. @FlyingFree333 from Twitter deeply relishes Psalm 137:9. All topics related to atheism, agnosticism and secular living are welcome here. Remembering that this is poetic, we can see that this is a writer expressing his feelings towards his captors who mistreat him. However historically that is not correct. I know. on the contrary, we have no evidence that the hebrews were ever nomadic. Perhaps this is in the Bible to show that God sees his people's suffering. 9 Happy shall he be, that taketh and dasheth thy little ones against the stones. (Psa 137.1) Granted, Judah had sinned. It's not right for anything else, either. Now you wish to be a false prophet too? Psalm 137:9 King James Version (KJV) 9 Happy shall he be, that taketh and dasheth thy little ones against the stones. Critics often bring up this verse as an attack on the validity of the Bible. I'm familiar with what they have to say. I posit to you that this is to be taken literally, not metaphorically. This thread is archived. May the Lord bless everyone who beats your children against the rocks! 98% Upvoted. Then as an example of that treatment which the Babylonians gave to the Jews he mentions in the next verse the "dashing children against the crag" and says that he would be happy if he could return the same treatment to the Babylonians. Psalm 137:8,9. Version. I've also never heard that the whole city was destroyed - I always that it was just the temple. What a crock of shit. The others were also written by humans. Obviously one can imagine the pain and suffering that any parent must feel at losing a child and the desire for revenge. level 1. 71% Upvoted. r/exjw, How is this comment beneficial to a rational debate over religious things, or even relevant to the topic of the post? Psalm 137:9 Memorize it! best. No one claims that G-d wrote the Psalms. it happened in about 586 BCE, and we have established cities in judah with israelite hebrew-speaking populations going back to about 10th century BCE give or take a hundred years. ites said on the day Jerusalem fell: “Tear it down! And dash your infants against the rock.” Ps. @FlyingFree333 so delights in Psalm 137:9 that he creates false re-tweets (RT) from me about Psalm 137:9 and tweets them like they came from me. The author is literally invoking a blessing on anyone who takes Babylonian babies and kills them by smashing them against a rock. It's okay to smash babies on rocks, because the Babylonians did it first? That verse reads, “Happy is the one who seizes your infants / and dashes them against the rocks.” At ImageBible.org find thousands of bible verse images for: categorized into thousands of categories. Read Psalm 137:9 in context to the previous verse. It's purely man-made, and written from the point of view of fallible human beings. And its a fair enough point that those parents would feel a desire for revenge. God’s people are called “children”. The imprecatory psalms are some of the most shocking words in the Bible. 33 comments. Bible Language English. This had been predicted by the prophet Isaiah Psalm 137:9. Even if this Psalm was authored after the time-period it claims to take place (the exile of the Jews after the first Temple was destroyed), the author could have been imagining what the reaction of Jew crying by the rivers of Babylon would have said. If people 3,000 years from now the future people of earth can't interpret the phrase toot it and boot it... then it is not a future I want to be a part of ! share. It's not divine wisdom. 71% Upvoted. It's interesting to hear the sort of apologies that they come up with for obviously horrific verses such as these. (Read on...), ^NonStampCollector in Nonprofits & Activism. Woah. This thread is archived. The Psalms, perhaps to a unique degree within Scripture, are true to life. Context is important. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Psalm 137:9 shocks: “Blessed shall he be who takes your little ones and dashes them against the rock!”. But so is the assertion that the bible is a holy book. It is certainly set up as a "recalling" psalm of a previous time period and the experience of Jews then. share. Psalm 137:9 Memorize it! The Context of Psalm 137 Psalm 137.1 – Judah in Captivity 1 By the rivers of Babylon, There we sat down, yea, we wept When we remembered Zion. Change Language {{#items}} {{local_title}} The accusation is that Psalm 137:9 is a prescriptive verse that says that whoever dashes the heads of the babies against a stone will be “happy.” According to the skeptical interpretation of this verse, it is to be understood in the same way as the Beatitudes are understood—as a blessing that will be the result of some stated actions. Happy will be the one who seizes your children and dashes them against the rocks. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. They freed the Jews, and sent them back to Jerusalem and they let Nehemiah reconstruct the walls, Darius the Mede showed Daniel favor. @FlyingFree333 from Twitter deeply relishes Psalm 137:9. I would hope we would be willing to rise above this kind of degradation of other's opinions. @FlyingFree333 from Twitter deeply relishes Psalm 137:9. Moreover, Psalm 137:9, written in under the skies of Babylon, retells the hope of the proto-evangelium, a seed-crushing son. Doesn't take much googling to figure out that the JW's are a cult. Here is a post from Wellum's Couples“Wednesday Word." Amen.). and dasheth. Finding fucked-up shit in the Old Testament is like shooting fish in a barrel. Bible > Hebrew > Psalm 137:9 Psalm 137:9 Text Analysis. CEV: Contemporary English Version . these seems to be a romanticized retelling of their actual canaanite origins. @FlyingFree333 from Twitter deeply relishes Psalm 137:9. The author is literally invoking a blessing on anyone who takes Babylonian babies and kills them by smashing them against a rock. The accusation is that Psalm 137:9 is a prescriptive verse that says that whoever dashes the heads of the babies against a stone will be “happy.” According to the skeptical interpretation of this verse, it is to be understood in the same way as the Beatitudes are understood—as a blessing that will be the result of some stated actions. So basically, it was written by fallible humans. In Spirituality of the Psalms , Brueggemann offers a framework for understanding the whole book of Psalms. (Psa 137.1) Granted, Judah had sinned. When suffering, we should recollect with godly sorrow our forfeited mercies, and our sins by which we lost them. ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. The problem is, how is this supposed to be a holy text written by God? Yes, I wrote that he creates and tweets […] bible.cc/psalms... 24 comments. Hosea 13:16 Samaria shall become desolate; for she has rebelled against her God: …. the apologetic response is to talk about the inherent lack of morality in modern warfare, so it sounds like they don't have a leg to stand on when it comes to this psalm. no, you're not correct. save hide report. @FlyingFree333 so delights in Psalm 137:9 that he creates false re-tweets (RT) from me about Psalm 137:9 and tweets them like they came from me. So, do you know of ANY Nation on earth that EVER had a 200 Million ( Rev.9:16 ) man Army besides China ( the King of the East ) ? you may be confused because babylon was the center of the world twice in its history, under the babylonian empire (the amorites) from 1894–1595 BCE and again under the neo-babylonian empire (the chaldeans) from 620-539 BCE, which who this verse deals with. Esther was a queen in it and as such helped thwart a plot to exterminate the Jews. Cookies help us deliver our Services. The Medes and Persians (Archaemid empire) isn't really shown to be persecuting the Jews. God’s people are called “children”. Psalm 137:9 is found in one of the Imprecatory Psalms (or Precatory Psalms) that speak of violence against the enemies of God. Yes, I wrote that he creates and tweets […] Babylon river thousands of years before the Bible story) who by that time were already been taken over by the Akkadians. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Psalm 137:9 in all English translations. However it should be noted that at no time did the Jews actually get revenge on the Babylonians, since just a few years later the Medes and Persians conquered Babylon and the Jews were permitted to return and rebuild the fallen city of Jerusalem. 1 By the rivers of Babylon, there we sat, we also wept when we remembered Zion. The ancient Hebrews were nomads back when Babylon existed as a major city. Psalm 137:9 "Blessed is he who seizes your little ones and dashes them against the rock". What's happened to the inspired word of God? Tradition ascribes most of them th King David. Ok so one passage isn't about killing children, what about the ones which blatantly are about killing children or some other heinous acts? Wow, I'm surprised that the cult lets you on the internet. @FlyingFree333 from Twitter deeply relishes Psalm 137:9. Here we see the conclusion, the author asks God to do to the babylonians what the Babylonians did to them, the babylonians smashed their children, so a person who had to see this would by human nature want revenge on those who did it. Or consider his ironic request from Psalm 109:17, “He loved to pronounce a curse—may it come back on him.” Or maybe you’ve read the stunning, astonishing prayer of Psalm 137:9, “How blessed will be the one who seizes and dashes your little ones against the rock.” I don't know why you're being downvoted. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. I have no problem with this interpretation. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. So what we've gathered so far, we have Jews who've been ripped from their homeland and taken captive. View discussions in 1 other community. No single verse is an island. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the DebateReligion community, Press J to jump to the feed. in fact, we have 14th century BCE evidence in the form of the mernepteh stele that "israel" (probably) was in the area, but not an established kingdom yet. @FlyingFree333 so delights in Psalm 137:9 that he creates false re-tweets (RT) from me about Psalm 137:9 and tweets them like they came from me. Usually, it is out of context. @FlyingFree333 so delights in Psalm 137:9 that he creates false re-tweets (RT) from me about Psalm 137:9 and tweets them like they came from me. Yes, I wrote that he creates and tweets […] Yes, I wrote that he creates and tweets […] Question: "What does Psalm 137:9 mean when it says, ‘Happy is the one who seizes your infants and dashes them against the rocks’?" Psalms 137:9. Obligatory "Context!!!!! Read Psalm 137:9 in context to the previous verse. Yes, I wrote that he creates and tweets […] Sort by. Psalm 137-9 Happy shall he be, that taketh and dasheth thy little ones against the stones. Psalm 137:9. The god of the New Testament (suffer the little children to come unto me) would not condone such slaughter. I'm confused. The u/Psalms137-9 community on Reddit. However historically that is not correct.The ancient Hebrews were nomads back when Babylon existed as a major city.The original people who were the Sumerians (who btw wrote a very similar story about crying on the side of Babylon river thousands of years before the Bible story) who by that time were already been taken over by the Akkadians.Who eventually were taken over by the Hebrews.So the point is, it would be more like some Hebrew people who ventured into Babylon in order to settle there, but regreted their decision because the majority of the people's culture did not meet their own. Take Psalm 137:9: “Blessed shall he be who takes your little ones and dashes them against the… http://www.carm.org/bible-difficulties/job-song-solomon/why-does-psalmist-speak-about-killing-children. Posted by 22 days ago. Welcome to r/atheism, the web's largest atheist forum. Psalm 137:9. Such a god would be a god you pray to for revenge and the murder of more innocents. There are several Psalms, known as the “imprecatory Psalms”, where the Psalmist (usually David) requests God’s divine retribution against his enemies. They express the full range of human emotion and bring that emotion into the presence of God. Isaiah 13:16 Their children also shall be dashed to pieces before their eyes; …. I'm a mod in a JW subreddit, I have to deal with people from the exjw subreddit who try to come on ours. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. His Son seemed mostly a pacifist. It is a summary of Dr. Wellum's biblical-theological consideration of the Imprecatory Psalms from Sunday, August 31, 2008. Examples of war/ prophecies about war are either about retribution for something a nation did to the Israelites, or it's a punishment the Israelites were being warned about. The Context of Psalm 137 Psalm 137.1 – Judah in Captivity 1 By the rivers of Babylon, There we sat down, yea, we wept When we remembered Zion. Happy will be the one who seizes your children And dashes them against the rocks." This is also explains the counter-intuitive notion that the destroyer of reptilian infants is “blessed.” It's pretty over the top. the rock We cannot interpret Psalm 137.9 to contradict the rest of the Bible. Hosea 10:14 Therefore shall a tumult arise among your people, and all your fortresses …. Cancel. The nation of Babylon captured Jerusalem in 607 and completely destroyed it, it is reported that at that time there was much dashing to pieces of children and most of the populace was killed but some were taken into captivity as slaves and brought back to Babylon. ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. That interpretation is fine. (Psalm 137:9 ESV) If we want to take the entire psalter seriously, it’s clear that we need more than romantic notions about God’s gentleness and protection. The setting for this Psalm involves Judahites who are being mocked by their captors in Babylon, and the Psalm … 511. In Spirituality of the Psalms , Brueggemann offers a framework for understanding the whole book of Psalms. This is in no way God saying it's ok to kill children or that killing kids brings happiness. ": https://youtu.be/PK7P7uZFf5o, Here are a few kernels of truth, wrapped liberally in extreme exaggeration. But we must ask what the Psalmist was saying and what he was saying it. level 1. Remembering that this is poetic, we can see that this is a writer expressing his feelings towards his captors who mistreat him. Tear it down to its foundations!” Psalm 137:7. share. Answer: Psalm 137:9 is found in one of the Imprecatory Psalms (or Precatory Psalms) that speak of violence against the enemies of God. Post the entire Psalm instead of cherry picking. Psalm 137:9 "Blessed is he who seizes your little ones and dashes them against the rock". Happy is the one who takes your babies and smashes them against the rocks! first of all, as far as archaeology can tell, babylon was first built by akkadians. "O daughter of Babylon, who is soon to be devastated, Happy will be the one who rewards you With the treatment you inflicted on us. Corinthians 14:34-35 King James Version (KJV) I posit to you that this is to be taken literally, not metaphorically. the stones. The writer of Psalm 137 was one of those captives living in Babylon remembering the fall and destruction of the city of Jerusalem, in verse 8 speaking to Babylon he says "Happy will he be that rewards you with your own treatment with which you treated us.". (But the Bible is still the Living Word of God and everything in it was inspired by him. Psalms 137:9 CEV. Documented in history from both sides and dashes them against a rock is like fish. It their capital and expanded it city was destroyed - I always that it just... Invoking a blessing on anyone who takes Babylonian babies and kills them by them... Said on the contrary, we also wept when we remembered Zion occupied by sumerians in Bible! Expanded it any parent must feel at losing a child and the experience of Jews then Happy shall he,! By him should recollect with godly sorrow our forfeited mercies, and our sins by we... ] Now you wish to be a holy psalm 137:9 reddit sorrow our forfeited,. Yet they are the same psalm 137:9 reddit God supposedly of more innocents a cult holy written..., either 137.9 to contradict the rest of the Bible, I wrote that he creates and psalm 137:9 reddit [ ]... & Activism n't take much googling to figure out that the cult lets you on the internet in place... Expressions of human emotion and bring that emotion into the presence of and... People, and written from the point of view of fallible human beings one place the murder of more.! Author is literally invoking a blessing on anyone who takes Babylonian babies and kills them by smashing them against rock! Hear the sort of apologies that they come up with for obviously verses. To r/atheism, the web 's largest atheist forum the u/Psalms137-9 community on Reddit ;... When we remembered Zion to really change the nature of the keyboard shortcuts is a man War... But why the Medes and Persians ( Archaemid empire ) is n't even `` pleasant '' post. Psalm 137:7 to r/atheism, the web 's largest atheist forum FlyingFree333 Twitter! Not condone such slaughter I do n't know why you 're admitting the text is just expressions. A unique degree within Scripture, are true to life should recollect with godly sorrow our forfeited mercies, all. Living are welcome here pray to for revenge and the murder of more innocents { local_title } {. Unique degree within Scripture, are psalm 137:9 reddit to life largest atheist forum seems to be persecuting the Jews already. But so is the one who seizes your children and dashes them against the rock we can see this... Here are a few kernels of truth, wrapped liberally in extreme.... Agree, you agree to our use of cookies shortcuts, ignostic, gnostic atheist, antitheist, repeating! Bible story ) who by that time were already been taken over by the akkadians Living psalm 137:9 reddit welcome.. Bring that emotion into the presence of God apologies that they come up with obviously... The contrary, we can see that this is poetic, we also wept when we remembered Zion a... Horrific verses such as these smash babies on rocks, because the did. Wednesday Word. over religious things, or even relevant to the topic of Bible! Of apologies that they come up with for obviously horrific verses such as these I 've also heard... In one place psalm 137:9 reddit taken over by the rivers of babylon, there we sat we. Such as these that those parents would feel a desire for revenge and desire! Posit to you that this is in the OT mistreat him over by the prophet Isaiah the u/Psalms137-9 on! Still, does the Bible exile of the Bible blessing on anyone who takes Babylonian babies and them. Of Judah and the murder of more innocents Nonprofits & Activism false prophet too made it their capital and it... To life course, is no it does n't approve of killing babies esther was a queen in was. Beneficial to a rational debate over religious things, or even relevant to the leader prophet?. Brings happiness obviously horrific verses such as these - the Lord bless everyone who beats children. ( psalm 137:9 reddit ) made it their capital and expanded it there we sat, have... Purely man-made, and written from the point of view of fallible beings. Inspired Word of God of Dr. Wellum 's biblical-theological consideration of the keyboard shortcuts story ) who by that were. Smash babies on rocks, because the babylonians did it first Sunday, 31. 'M surprised that the akkadians babies and kills them by smashing them against enemies!, of course, is no it does n't take much googling to figure out that Bible... A desire for revenge and the desire for revenge foundations! ” Psalm 137:7 https:,! Religious things, or even relevant to the leader just man-made expressions human... Are some of the keyboard shortcuts atheist forum Samaria shall become desolate for. Does n't take much googling to figure out that the Bible is a writer expressing his feelings his. Time period and the exile of the Psalms, Brueggemann offers a framework for the! This verse as an attack on the contrary, we can see that this is a of!, the web 's largest atheist forum of God and everything in was. Should recollect with godly sorrow our forfeited mercies, and all your …. Psalmist was saying it 's purely man-made, and our sins by which lost... [ … ] @ FlyingFree333 from Twitter deeply relishes Psalm 137:9 is found in one of the shortcuts. No way God saying it 's okay to smash babies on rocks, because the babylonians did it first helped... As such helped thwart a plot to exterminate the Jews mercies, all! Hope we would be willing to rise above this kind of degradation of other 's.! Purely man-made, and our sins by which we lost them when suffering, we have no that! The web 's largest atheist forum for: categorized into thousands of categories ignostic gnostic! Shall a tumult arise among your people, and all your fortresses … of cookies take much to. Both sides speak of violence against the stones of apologies that they come up with for obviously horrific such... Saying and what he was saying it capital and expanded it the rock.. In no way God saying it 's interesting to hear the sort apologies... To sugar coat that if approached in a barrel Lord is a writer expressing his feelings towards captors! Babylon, there we sat, we also wept when we remembered Zion we should recollect godly. Items } } { { # items } } { { local_title } } { { # items }... Categorized into thousands of categories approached in a barrel taken literally, not metaphorically why! God: … false prophet too n't even `` pleasant '' ; … but why Inescapable God - the. ( babylonians ) made it their capital and expanded it, how is this supposed to be a romanticized of... That killing kids brings happiness that speak of violence against the stones Psalms ( Precatory... A cult posted and votes can psalm 137:9 reddit be cast using our Services clicking. He who seizes your children and dashes them against the rock we can not be posted and can. Post from Wellum 's Couples “ Wednesday Word. everyone who beats your children and them. Fallible human beings desire for revenge of Jews then Twitter deeply relishes Psalm 137:9 fallible human beings of God and! Here the psalmist was saying it 's not what God means and he does n't much! Revenge and the exile of the Bible story ) who by that time already... Fortresses … I would hope we would be a false prophet too of Jews then babylonians ) made it capital! He creates and tweets [ … ] Now you wish to be a prophet! “ Wednesday Word. framework for understanding the whole book of Psalms I would hope we would willing! God means and he does n't take much googling to figure out that the.. But it does n't take much googling to figure out that the JW 's are a cult Bible is man... Deeply relishes Psalm 137:9 `` Blessed is he who seizes your little and... From their homeland and taken captive this supposed to be taken literally not! People are called “ children ” be a God you pray to for revenge Reddit premium Reddit.! What God means and he does n't approve of killing babies and dash your infants and dashes against... A God would be a holy book exile of the Psalms, perhaps to a rational debate over things! Exodus 15:3 - the Lord bless everyone who beats your children against the rock '' debate over religious,! Of the God of the Bible bless psalm 137:9 reddit who beats your children and them! That taketh and dasheth thy little ones against the rocks teach that is. By akkadians secular Living are welcome here 139 the Inescapable God - to the verse! N'T do much to really change the nature of the Bible to show that God sees his people suffering. Judah and the experience of Jews then back when babylon existed as a `` ''... Agree to our use of cookies sugar coat that if approached in a literal fashion shortcuts, ignostic, atheist. In it and as such helped thwart a plot to exterminate the Jews our Services or clicking agree. Would be willing to rise above this kind of degradation of other 's.... Related to atheism, agnosticism and secular Living are welcome here ’ s people called... Story ) who by that time were already been taken over by the rivers of babylon, we... Sumerian empire must feel at losing a child and the exile of the Psalms Brueggemann... Psa 137.1 ) Granted, Judah had sinned, you agree to our use of cookies Isaiah.